Announcement

Collapse

Forum Rules

  • No flaming or derogatory remarks, directly or through insinuation.
  • No discussion, sharing or referencing illegal software such as hacks, keygen, cracks and pirated software.
  • No offensive contents, including but not limited to, racism, gore or pornography.
  • No excessive spam/meme, i.e. copious one liners in a short period of time, typing with all caps or posting meme responses (text/image).
  • No trolling, including but not limited to, flame incitation, user provocation or false information distribution.
  • No link spamming or signature advertisements for content not specific to Dota 2.
  • No Dota 2 key requests, sell, trade etc.
  • You may not create multiple accounts for any purpose, including ban evasion, unless expressly permitted by a moderator.

  • Please search before posting. One thread per issue. Do not create another thread if there is an existing one already.
  • Before posting anything, make sure you check out all sticky threads (e.g., this). Do not create new threads about closed ones.
  • It is extremely important that you post in correct forum section.

  • Balance discussion only in Misc.
  • All art related (such as hero model) feedbacks go to Art Feedback Forum.
  • All matchmaking feedback should go here: Matchmaking Feedback
  • All report/low priority issues should go here: Commend/Report/Ban Feedback
  • No specific workshop item feedback. These should go to workshop page of that item.
  • When posting in non-bugs section (such as this), use [Bugs], [Discussion] or [Suggestion] prefix in your thread name.



In case you object some action by a moderator, please contact him directly through PM and explain your concerns politely. If you are still unable to resolve the issue, contact an administrator. Do not drag these issues in public.



All rules are meant to augment common sense, please use them when not conflicted with aforementioned policies.
See more
See less

"Easier" Bots don't seem to be easy enough for learning purposes

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • "Easier" Bots don't seem to be easy enough for learning purposes

    I've been trying to get some friends who play LoL, into playing Dota 2. And starting out in Bot matches with them is an obvious choice. But.. it seems not so much these days.

    I remember much earlier in the beta, when the bots weren't as refined, that they would be quite derpy on Easy setting, being fairly easy to win against and not playing against you aggressively. But now, even on the "Easier" setting, the bots play quite aggressively and will push lanes quite early. And two times in a row, there was a vengeful spirit roaming to our top Jungle/Lane to gank, before any creeps had even spawned (one time it was a hair away from successful against one of our derpy bots). Why is that kind of behavior happening on the easiest setting??

    Now I'm not saying they are super hard or anything, but for a player coming from LoL, it would be nice to have a quite easy bot setting that they can take their time with and get the basics of this game down with first, instead of becoming frustrated from being killed by bots and not feeling like playing the game anymore because of it.

    The "Easier" bots are harder than a lot of random live games one might play in, simply due to the bots being able to communicate so well compared to a lobby of jumbled players who may or may not be newish players.

    (And I know, some may say, "well, how will they learn if it's not challenging", but they will. Because having easy bots like that is merely about allowing a person to easily grasp the basic gameplay concepts without becoming frustrated. Then as they get comfortable with it and start liking the game, they will move on to the harder bots and learn to actually play well.)
    D̶̪̏̇͛͂̈̊̏O̬͉̱̭̤̐ͤ͝T̥̼̗̦̯͙ͣ͐ͮͨ͛̐Ä̩̣̖̘̖͍̹͐ͮ̊ͣ̆̎ ̗͖̘̲̝͔̅͐̀̎͗͌̐2̢̔̄ͭ̋͌̾

  • #2
    this is the basic thing you need to learn about dota. Dota is hard! just kid

    anyway, agree on OP though. bot behaviour should be set easier/simpler for new player to get a grasp of playing dota.so +1
    "Knowledge is knowing that a tomato is a fruit, but Wisdom is knowing not to put it in a fruit salad."

    Comment


    • #3
      Yeah, Easier bots should be realy bad. I agree OP

      +1
      Originally posted by vladhood
      boy im glad all these qualified and educated game designers have come to the forums to help dota 2 grow

      Comment


      • #4
        OP: Were you playing a coop matchmade game vs bots, or a private lobby?

        Comment


        • #5
          A private lobby with the friend.
          D̶̪̏̇͛͂̈̊̏O̬͉̱̭̤̐ͤ͝T̥̼̗̦̯͙ͣ͐ͮͨ͛̐Ä̩̣̖̘̖͍̹͐ͮ̊ͣ̆̎ ̗͖̘̲̝͔̅͐̀̎͗͌̐2̢̔̄ͭ̋͌̾

          Comment


          • #6
            I agree that bots can be really annoying even on very easy difficulties. For instance, VS + jugg bots on easier difficulty will swap you on sight into Jugg then stun you, and Jugg will bladestorm you, all with perfect timing, every time you show up. That's 1000+ damage at level 6. Bane is equally as annoying and doesn't leave a chance to the player even at Easier and perfectly chains his spells together.

            For a new/noob player that's a guaranteed death every time he shows up in the lane. And a guaranteed uninstall LOL. +1

            As a suggestion, I would add a "human" factor to the bots. That means, give the bots a respond time before they actually do their things, as humans do. That could be a random number between 0.00 and 1.00 second, or something like that, and would vary according to difficulty.

            Comment


            • #7
              A chance to screw up spell cast order, or missing skillshots more frequently, and less teamwork.

              They clump up as a team of 5 and combo like madmen.

              Comment


              • #8
                I totally agree. When I was learning the game, Zeus always getting kills when I was low on health and VG and Sven stun locking, almost got me to quit the game. Thankfully I had some friends to teach and play with me so I could learn the game.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Sounds like we need to add more Easy mode hooks, right now it's not all that different from Normal. Good feedback, that's the kind of thing that's hard to gauge internally -- thanks everyone.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Agreed. I was going to post a topic about the difference between Passive and Easier being really quite a leap and bounds difference.

                    I came from League of Legends to give DOTA 2 a fair shake since I really didn't like all the nay saying I kept hearing one way or the other on the LOL forums.
                    Once I got an actual handle on last hitting/denial, DOTA 2's items, the difference in playstyle approach versus LoL (much longer laning phase, holding off aggression from the start, the entire learning curve versus a cliff) then I've basically been able to cream passive mode once I manage to feed myself on gold enough to start pushing down all the towers since, well, doesn't seem like the AI does much at all.

                    I've played a few easier and normal matches; it can be hard to tell. So if you can do those hooks I'm sure it'll help myself and those I invite to sign up for the beta from LoL more.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Woot! Thanks Chris, glad to hear you guys will take a look into changing it up some more. Awesome when threads get results so quickly hehe. You guys are doing a great job
                      D̶̪̏̇͛͂̈̊̏O̬͉̱̭̤̐ͤ͝T̥̼̗̦̯͙ͣ͐ͮͨ͛̐Ä̩̣̖̘̖͍̹͐ͮ̊ͣ̆̎ ̗͖̘̲̝͔̅͐̀̎͗͌̐2̢̔̄ͭ̋͌̾

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        I agree.
                        I think the main problem are the friendly bots. It's like 5 bots can communicate super good and all, but 4 bots and 1 player doesn't work out too good, that's also why I pratice only in Coop matches against bots.
                        I feel like you can't play an initiator or support in a bot match (9 bots, 1 player). So for example you initiate in a team fight, but the bots feel like no I won't attack and then you get killed. That's just really frustrating.

                        I recommend that you and your friend should rather practice in a coop match. It's just so much more fun

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Yep, easy bots are still not "easy" enough for newcomers.

                          The main difference in most bot modes are the small increase of reaction times and the passiveness on the laning phase (on easier modes, bots don't deny or harass).

                          Main problem I found is: unless playing on Passive mode (bots will stick the entire game farming their lanes), ganks are done as early as at lv2, cluttering and player focusing are too common, and there's still the "enemy team roams and pushes as a compact 5 bot_squad_of_death while my team bots keep farming or pushing after I've already pinged 40 times for them to defend the tower, then, once the tower is down, they stay behind or engage enemy bots (one at a time) geting themselves killed" issue.

                          Still, we all know there's already a lot of work to do, but here are some ideas to make bots "easier"

                          1-. Difficulty undependant configuration for bot denying, harassing in lane and even ganking/roaming, thus you can play an "easy" match with harassing and denying bots. Maybe even sliders instead of on/off switches (the higher the setting, the more "will" bots'll have to gank/harass/deny and the earlier they'll start doing it; a lower setting will make bots less willing, or wait for longer till they start roaming/harassing for example)

                          2-. Separate reaction times depending on situation and action taken and some external sources. Actual bot rt's are undependant of the action taken and too low... many players, specially newcomers, will range rt of 500-1000ms on average depending on the situation.

                          * Last hitting. Low rt, medium window (150ms - 400ms window), making the window smaller the harder the bots. Last hitting is a repetitive action done a lot, but you must take into account damage being dealt to the creep, your damage, the attack animation and (in case of ranged heroes) the projectile flight speed. Even advanced players fail last hitting from time to time., and trying to last hit too soon or too late is actually pretty common when you're first learning the game.

                          * Denying. Same as last hitting, a little higher on lower difficulty settings (200ms - 450ms). Basic deny idea is to "last hit your creep" so in general terms the windows should be the same, but as a starting player you mainly concentrate on last hitting enemy creeps and, if having "spare time" then look for denying your creeps. While advanced players will deny atmost as if they were lat hitting (thus having the same rt for a lasthit and for a deny), newcomers must actively "think" of denying, thus the little higher rt.

                          * Comboing and stuns/disables. "no rt", big window, (-600ms - +300ms window) making the window smaller the higher the dificulty. This is a pretty tricky one. Currently, even in easier dificulty settings, bot timing is almost perfect: you get stunned, bots hit you, when the stun is wearing off another perfect stun lands = you dead. First of all, you may have an idea how much time your teammate's stun will last, but don't know exactly when he/she clicked, so you tend to pre-cast your stun so it lands when the enemy is still stunned, "losing" some stun time (the "minus" value, you land your stun before the previous one wears off); also, if you try to get a "perfect" combo, you may click too late allowing the enemy a small posibility of running away (the "plus" value). Advanced players "combo" better, so they'll lessen the window, but still fail sometimes (yesterday - 11/Apr/2012 - games on JoinDota with QoP and SK evades in some of Tobi's streamed games are perfect examples of this)

                          * Initiated/taken by surprise (+500ms to +1500ms added to the next rt, smaller the higher the difficulty). You get surprised, you react slower, simple as that. Advanced players recover faster from the surprise, but still need some time to react. Medium driver reaction time in most countries is one second (1000ms) when reacting to road hazards, and even higher for people who got their driving license recently.

                          3-. Longer laning phase and lesser roaming will for easier difficulty settings (if undependant settings in 1 are enabled). Most newcomers want to test "the whole thing" including ganks and harassment, but will prefer a longer laning phase so they "get warmed".

                          4-. Extreme will for allied bots to react to player pings (almost considered as an order). If you ping an allied tower, you're ordering a defend and you expect bots to come even by foot, not for them to keep roaming or pushing other lanes the next three minutes while enemy team gets T1, T2, T3 and 'racks. If you ping your ancient, you call a base defense. If you ping an enemy tower, you're ordering a push, If you ping an enemy bot you order a focus and so on. An alternate set of orders could be to ping a particular allied bot (clicking on him/her or in their portrait), and then issue a "ping", so that "ping" is only meant to them (this could even be used to assign bots to lanes if you click on a bot and then on an allied T1 tower on the 1:30 granted time before game starts, If no orders are issued in 0:45 minutes, bots will auto-chose their lanes)

                          5-. Lower will fot the enemy team to form a 5-bot-squad-of death after mid-game starts. This is still one of the worst problems with bots in all difficulties. Enemy team starts roaming as a full squad while your team is split here and there. 2-3 gank roams should be more common (while other bots keep farming, pushing or defending), and your team should behave the same way (for example, a ganker+support roam). If your team "detects" a 5-bot-enemy-roam, they should immediately assume a full scale push/roshan and get themselves ready.

                          ... and some others.
                          Last edited by Yorien; 04-12-2012, 05:38 AM.
                          "+1. This is no WC3 DotA. Evolve or return to your cave."

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Just to add my 2 cents on this issue...

                            I was playing with my IRL mate, a casual HoN player when it was in it's infancy.

                            Decided to go into a bot match where the AI decided to rip us royal in the first 20 minutes, ganking with 5 heroes all around the map, dominating everything with magically farmed items which made the last 20 minutes of the game quite eerie when they didn't even leave their base allowing us to just walk in and end it.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Fully agree with the reaction times issue. Tiny bot in particular is an unkillable force of nature-- he Avalanche and Toss comboes so effectively it almost seems like one fluid attack. As for the 5-man ganking squads of death, this too needs to be toned down. While the enemy team is murdering a tower, my team are running back and forth behind it, initiate, get chain-stunned and comboed to oblivion, then the enemy team continues to push and wins the game.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X