PERMANENT BAN (MAC ADDRESS SO THEY NEED TO CHANGE MOTHERBOARD)

[phormix]

It really does seem that some people are completely unphased by the current system. Really, even if you DO end up getting somebody low-prio'ed, that just means they have problems getting into a game quickly. So they go slow, but meanwhile they still can ruin games for 4-7 people at a time depending on how bad they're screwing things up.

A lot of dedicated a-holes really don't care, they'll just sit around and do whatever until they get into their low-prio games, and possibly behave for a bit until it's time to troll again. A hardware/userid specific, long-term BAN would be an improvement for the game for everyone.

[phormix]

The MAC would be a fairly strong unique identifier it the client can read it, but if it's reading things at that hardware level there's also often CPUID's and other such on modern hardware

[BlinkingRiki182]

Just to be clear.

I meant that your local MAC (src) changes in the ethernet frame header to the router's MAC every time a router is passed.

If you for example serialize an object that contains a string member which contains your local MAC Address and send it via TCP, then this one won't change.

And yes, spoofing on driver basis is the "best". Unless Valve Software writes their own NIC drivers and uses them.

Once again, the problem here is terminology and nothing else. I refer to "your local MAC" as the MAC that you use in your own network. From your perspective and the perspective of the people that reside in your network, your MAC doesn't change, from the perspective of outside observers (not behind your router), your MAC changes but I wouldn't refer to the src MAC in the MAC tables of other routers (not your own) as "local MAC". Let's say your local IP is 198.168.0.2, do you say that your local IP changes for people that get traffic from you, who are outside of your network? They get the internet IP assigned to your router. In the same manner, people can trace "your" MAC by scanning "your" internet IP and they'll get the MAC of your router. They'll just hop through all nodes to the final source MAC, that of your router. They'll get a pretty useless MAC if they get it from the ethernet frame header of the traffic they receive from you, that makes zero sense.

[wolf633]

If your NIC driver allows that, you can change the MAC at driver level thus the Valve Software will read the "spoofed" MAC. Furthermore, you can always monitor outgoing traffic and manipulate the TCP packets created by said software and inject the spoofed MAC, even if the drivers of your network card do support changing the MAC.

L2 switches do use MAC address tables to pass the traffic around. That doesn't mean that your local MAC "changes", it doesn't (it "changes" for outside observers that are not in your network e.g. not behind your router). Outside observers can't get your MAC in this case anyway because they will get the MAC of the router (by scanning your internet IP). The way they can get it is, as you've said, if your machine sends it to them (e.g. Valve Software).

Just to be clear.

I meant that your local MAC (src) changes in the ethernet frame header to the router's MAC every time a router is passed.

If you for example serialize an object that contains a string member which contains your local MAC Address and send it via TCP, then this one won't change.

And yes, spoofing on driver basis is the "best". Unless Valve Software writes their own NIC drivers and uses them.

[BlinkingRiki182]

It does change. Both the src and dst MAC addresses; every time a frame or ip packet passes a router. It's used for per network communication, as I already said. For example if you have L2 switches in the next network and you don't change the MAC, those switches would be unable to continue sending the packets.

MAC spoofing won't help you "pass" those bans. Because Valve Software would read your actual NIC's MAC address and put it into another Layer, for example in a TCP packet. And spoofing only changes the ethernet frame header.

If your NIC driver allows that, you can change the MAC at driver level thus the Valve Software will read the "spoofed" MAC. Furthermore, you can always monitor outgoing traffic and manipulate the TCP packets created by said software and inject the spoofed MAC, even if the drivers of your network card do support changing the MAC.

L2 switches do use MAC address tables to pass the traffic around. That doesn't mean that your local MAC "changes", it doesn't (it "changes" for outside observers that are not in your network e.g. not behind your router). Outside observers can't get your MAC in this case anyway because they will get the MAC of the router (by scanning your internet IP). The way they can get it is, as you've said, if your machine sends it to them (e.g. Valve Software).

[wolf633]

Each card has an unique MAC address assigned that cannot be "changed" (in some cases it's embedded in the network card's ROM and in some cases is embedded in the drivers). The thing is, regardless of network card hardware capabilities, you can change the MAC that is encapsulated in the TCP or the UDP packet (MAC spoof). Your MAC address doesn't change when you change networks.

It does change. Both the src and dst MAC addresses; every time a frame or ip packet passes a router. It's used for per network communication, as I already said. For example if you have L2 switches in the next network and you don't change the MAC, those switches would be unable to continue sending the packets.

MAC spoofing won't help you "pass" those bans. Because Valve Software would read your actual NIC's MAC address and put it into another Layer, for example in a TCP packet. And spoofing only changes the ethernet frame header.

[GermanViet]

MAC address is only used in your local network but it is still unique. It is not networked into the internet (just by communicating with a website they won't have your MAC address). But if you have their programs installed they can extract the information from your PC and send it to themselves. There are other hardwares (CPU, SSD, graphic card) in your rig that probably have a unique identifier.

Whether you should do hardware bans or not is another topic in itself. Valve chose not to do it. And there are good reasons for it. What if your hardware is banned because a cheater spoofed your HWID by chance?

[BlinkingRiki182]

You don't need to change them. They change automatically when the ethernet frames jump from one network into another. They are just used per network.

So bans based on MAC addresses would only work within a single network. And I don't think Valve uses the MAC addresses at all.

And you don't have to change the motherboard. Just install another NIC and you should be fine.

Each card has an unique MAC address assigned that cannot be "changed" (in some cases it's embedded in the network card's ROM and in some cases is embedded in the drivers). The thing is, regardless of network card hardware capabilities, you can change the MAC that is encapsulated in the TCP or the UDP packet (MAC spoof). Your MAC address doesn't change when you change networks.

[wolf633]

You can easily change your MAC address though. Just so you know.

You don't need to change them. They change automatically when the ethernet frames jump from one network into another. They are just used per network.

So bans based on MAC addresses would only work within a single network. And I don't think Valve uses the MAC addresses at all.

And you don't have to change the motherboard. Just install another NIC and you should be fine.

[BlinkingRiki182]

Hi
I got a quick question regarding people who need to be banned permanently..

Match ID: 2502283034

Silencer is AFK from start
Comes back 4 mins later or something like that, right cliks on me (Tiny) and goes afk again.. I go forward lane to farm, didn't notice he is on follow mode, he dies.. I ask to be reported. He jumps and starts acting shitty (sorry), saying he gon' feed. Ruins our game, like totally.. CAPTAIN'S MODE, and he afk's..

So.. Is there a way to ban these guys permanently, put their MAC address to the ban list, so they won't be able to join games, like EVER, in their lifetimes?
I mean he INTENTIONALLY ruined my game, and we had it, we had that win.

Low prio is not enough for people like him.

Can you please do something about this case, and other cases such as this?
Thank you.

P.S.
Sorry for posting this here, couldn't find an appropirate section to ask this question.

P.P.S.
Yes, he is reported, from all the players in the Rad team, and probably (not sure though), from Dire.
But I know it won't cut it.

You can easily change your MAC address though. Just so you know.

[zharko4jc]

Hi
I got a quick question regarding people who need to be banned permanently..

Match ID: 2502283034

Silencer is AFK from start
Comes back 4 mins later or something like that, right cliks on me (Tiny) and goes afk again.. I go forward lane to farm, didn't notice he is on follow mode, he dies.. I ask to be reported. He jumps and starts acting shitty (sorry), saying he gon' feed. Ruins our game, like totally.. CAPTAIN'S MODE, and he afk's..

So.. Is there a way to ban these guys permanently, put their MAC address to the ban list, so they won't be able to join games, like EVER, in their lifetimes?
I mean he INTENTIONALLY ruined my game, and we had it, we had that win.

Low prio is not enough for people like him.

Can you please do something about this case, and other cases such as this?
Thank you.

P.S.
Sorry for posting this here, couldn't find an appropirate section to ask this question.

P.P.S.
Yes, he is reported, from all the players in the Rad team, and probably (not sure though), from Dire.
But I know it won't cut it.