Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 15

Thread: [Confirmed] Bane ulti wrong damage scale + missing tick on first use

  1. #1
    Basic Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    74

    [Confirmed] Bane ulti wrong damage scale + missing tick on first use

    Previous bug with bane http://dev.dota2.com/showthread.php?t=27710
    But this is somehow going further:

    First time EVER to use lvl 1 ulti on an enemy gives only 4 damage instances
    [01:02.66] Pudge receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Bane.
    [01:03.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (2449->2374).
    [01:04.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (2378->2303).
    [01:05.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (2307->2232).
    [01:06.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (2235->2160).
    [01:08.36] Bane hits Pudge for 66 damage (2167->2101).

    Second time to use lvl 1 ulti on an enemy gives 5 damage instances
    [01:11.73] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (2114->2039).
    [01:11.73] Pudge receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Bane.
    [01:12.76] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (2043->1968).
    [01:13.76] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (1972->1897).
    [01:14.76] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (1900->1825).
    [01:15.76] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (1829->1754).
    [01:17.36] Bane hits Pudge for 66 damage (1761->1695).

    First time to use lvl 2 ulti on an enemy gives 5 damage instances. But the first tick does lvl 1 damage
    [01:20.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 75 damage (1707->1632).
    [01:20.69] Pudge receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Bane.
    [01:21.73] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (1635->1519).
    [01:22.73] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (1522->1406).
    [01:23.73] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (1410->1294).
    [01:24.73] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (1298->1182).
    [01:26.26] Bane hits Pudge for 67 damage (1187->1120).

    Second time to use lvl 2 ulti on an enemy gives 5 damage instances. But now all all damage instances are from lvl 2
    [01:29.36] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (1132->1016).
    [01:29.36] Pudge receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Bane.
    [01:30.39] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (1020->904).
    [01:31.39] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (907->791).
    [01:32.39] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (795->679).
    [01:33.39] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (683->567).
    [01:34.96] Bane hits Pudge for 68 damage (572->504).

    First time to use lvl 3 ulti on an enemy give 5 damage instances. But the first tick does lvl 2 damage
    [01:38.86] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 116 damage (2449->2333).
    [01:38.86] Pudge receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Bane.
    [01:39.89] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (2337->2176).
    [01:40.89] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (2180->2019).
    [01:41.89] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (2022->1861).
    [01:42.89] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1865->1704).
    [01:44.39] Bane hits Pudge for 68 damage (1709->1641).

    Second time to use lvl 3 ulti on an enemy gives 5 damage instances. But now all all damage instances are from lvl 3
    [01:45.66] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1645->1484).
    [01:45.66] Pudge receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Bane.
    [01:46.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1488->1327).
    [01:47.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1330->1169).
    [01:48.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1172->1011).
    [01:49.69] Bane hits Pudge with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1015->854).
    [01:51.26] Bane hits Pudge for 69 damage (860->791).

    Edit:
    When Rubick steals the banes ulti it happens almost the same. The first use ever does not have the tick at t=0=gettingdebuff. BUT he has an extra damage tick at t=losingdebuff

    [21:06.41] Bane receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Rubick.
    [21:07.44] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1897->1736).
    [21:08.44] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1739->1578).
    [21:09.44] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1581->1420).
    [21:10.44] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1423->1262).
    [21:11.44] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1264->1103).
    [21:11.44] Bane loses FIEND'S GRIP debuff.
    [21:12.17] Rubick hits Bane for 55 damage (1105->1050).

    So for the seconds time casting the ulti Rubick can deal 6 instances.

    [21:14.84] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (1058->897).
    [21:14.84] Bane receives FIEND'S GRIP debuff from Rubick.
    [21:15.87] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (900->739).
    [21:16.87] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (742->581).
    [21:17.87] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (583->422).
    [21:18.87] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (425->264).
    [21:19.87] Rubick hits Bane with FIEND'S GRIP for 161 damage (267->106).
    [21:19.87] Bane loses FIEND'S GRIP debuff.
    [21:20.44] Rubick hits Bane for 55 damage (108->53).
    Last edited by Kunze-Waldemar; 10-29-2012 at 08:38 AM.

  2. #2
    Basic Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Shanghai/Hong Kong
    Posts
    2,880
    it's the same issue(i mean wrong damage scale + missing tick on first use r probably from the same problem). first time u used it, it justs account as lvl 0, thus 0 damage.
    Last edited by Eric37073; 10-29-2012 at 09:03 AM.

  3. #3
    Basic Member ThoAppelsin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Posts
    2,893
    The previous issue he has linked is about Fiend's Grip having 1 less tick all the time.
    Now, the Kunze guy is reporting that Bane is using the last tick of the previous Grip he has used as his first tick.

    The ticks throughout the game are basically shifted by 1 second. Meaning that if the first EVER tick was 1 second before, the first Grip would have 5 full ticks and the second Grip wouldn't began with the last tick of the previous. Or something like that...
    If the first tick has happened 1 second before, then everything would be in order.

  4. #4
    Basic Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    74
    What could be wrong with the 6 damage instances? I does not follow any logic.
    I randomly created Banes and Rubicks as friends and enemies. For further ultis they can do either 6 instances (at any time) or they can only do only 5 (at any time).

  5. #5
    Basic Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    11,187
    readded to sticky.
    Make sure to read the Forum Rules as well as the stickied Threads of the Forum Section you are posting in.

    Contributions i'd like to highlight:
    My Suggestion: Coaching System
    My Sticky: Intended Changes List
    My Challenge: Completely Fixed Hero Challenge: Skywrath Mage

  6. #6
    I'd like to bump this and say that this has gotten even worse.

    Bane is now ticking for a total of 6 ticks when he uses his ult instead of 5, meaning he does a heckuva lot more damage than the should be; his level 1 does 450 instead of 375---his level 2 does 696 instead of 580....and his level 3 does a whopping 966 instead of 805.

    This happens on "latest" patch and "tournament" patch---should bane even be allowed in the qualifiers with bugged damage like this? No idea if the duration is bugged too.

  7. #7
    Basic Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Shanghai/Hong Kong
    Posts
    2,880
    this is partially fixed. bane now deals correct ticks of damage on every levels of fiend's grip. however, rubick could still do 1 more tick of damage.
    Quote Originally Posted by Fox McCloud View Post
    I'd like to bump this and say that this has gotten even worse.

    Bane is now ticking for a total of 6 ticks when he uses his ult instead of 5, meaning he does a heckuva lot more damage than the should be; his level 1 does 450 instead of 375---his level 2 does 696 instead of 580....and his level 3 does a whopping 966 instead of 805.

    This happens on "latest" patch and "tournament" patch---should bane even be allowed in the qualifiers with bugged damage like this? No idea if the duration is bugged too.
    ty for bumping this. but i dont think what u said is true

  8. #8
    See for yourself:

    http://cloud-2.steampowered.com/ugc/...97BC9FE5F60BD/
    http://cloud-2.steampowered.com/ugc/...9CBFDEBE9F510/
    http://cloud-2.steampowered.com/ugc/...7ECE819D51882/

    This is a total of 6 ticks worth of damage; not 5.

    And in case you think it's just a visual glitch, here's a combat log. This is the VERY first time I made Bane use Fiend's grip--so there wasn't any overlapping from last time or the last one only doing 4 ticks. It's just plain ticking one more time than it should....it seems the total duration is fine:

    http://cloud-2.steampowered.com/ugc/...275035D7643D1/
    Last edited by Fox McCloud; 05-19-2013 at 01:06 AM.

  9. #9
    Basic Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Shanghai/Hong Kong
    Posts
    2,880
    [01:06.53] Bane hits Sven with Fiend's Grip for 75 damage (587->512).
    [01:06.53] Sven receives Fiend's Grip debuff from Bane.
    [01:07.56] Bane hits Sven with Fiend's Grip for 75 damage (513->438).
    [01:08.56] Bane hits Sven with Fiend's Grip for 75 damage (439->364).
    [01:09.56] Bane hits Sven with Fiend's Grip for 75 damage (365->290).
    [01:10.56] Bane hits Sven with Fiend's Grip for 75 damage (291->216).
    [01:11.56] Sven loses Fiend's Grip debuff.

    it's totally normal on my end

  10. #10
    Basic Member Kryil-'s Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    8,065
    Is this another "picked hero vs. -createhero" issue?
    If you think I've closed or deleted a post unjustified, feel free to PM me and I'll explain it to you/discuss it with you further.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •